Clarify the differences between the consulting-oriented approach in the ALRA and the academic-oriented approach in the agile literature review approach (ALRA): a note for Housing Studies students (information from perplexity.ai)
My question: "I would like to learn more about the differences between the agile literature review approach (the consulting-oriented type) and the agile literature review approach (the academic-oriented type) of Joseph Ho in the context of Housing Studies. Basically, the consulting-oriented type starts with heeding in a holistic way the concerns and problems of some specific clients and problem-owners and derive a set of research objectives from the concerns and problems, while the academic oriented approach derives a set of research objectives from a chosen number of research gaps due to the researcher's intellectual curiosity. With this information, please produce 2 dissertation proposals with a title, 4 research objectives and 2 research methods, one for the consulting-oriented proposal and another one for the academic-oriented one with reference to the research theme of "the relatedness between negative equity of housing property and domestic violence of the lower social class families in Wan Chai of Hong Kong in 2025".."
The reply: "Here are two dissertation proposals based on Joseph Ho’s agile literature review approaches applied to the theme of negative equity in housing and domestic violence among lower social class families in Wan Chai, Hong Kong, 2025.
Consulting-Oriented Dissertation Proposal
Research Objectives:
Identify the specific concerns and challenges faced by social service agencies and community organizations related to negative equity and domestic violence among lower-class families in Wan Chai.
Explore how negative equity in housing property influences the incidence and severity of domestic violence cases reported by front-line workers.
Develop actionable recommendations tailored to client organizations for mitigating domestic violence linked to negative equity stress.
Assess the effectiveness of current intervention programs in addressing the ripple effects of negative equity on family violence in the community.
Research Methods:
Qualitative interviews with social workers, NGO staff, and affected families in Wan Chai to gather first-hand problem definitions and contextual data.
Case study analysis of intervention programs to evaluate best practices and gaps.
Academic-Oriented Dissertation Proposal
Research Objectives:
Review existing literature to identify key research gaps concerning the link between negative housing equity and domestic violence in the lower social strata of Hong Kong.
Theorize possible mechanisms through which negative equity could exacerbate domestic violence, guided by social constructionist and critical realist perspectives.
Quantitatively analyze housing market data and police/domestic violence reports to test hypotheses derived from identified gaps.
Contribute to conceptual frameworks for understanding economic stressors in family violence among disadvantaged populations.
Research Methods:
Systematic literature review focusing on studies related to housing equity, domestic violence, and socioeconomic disadvantage.
Quantitative analysis using secondary datasets, such as housing price trends and crime statistics from Wan Chai in 2025, to validate theoretical claims."
No comments:
Post a Comment