Sunday, 15 October 2023

Refinement of management-concerns items: illustrative example 3

Refinement of management-concerns items: illustrative example 3. This note covers examples in zone 1, zone 2, zone 3a and zone 3b.


Example 1: "gold price appreciated" (zone 1 [environmental drivers] item)

Refined as: "Management concerned about the impact of gold price increase on depressing consumer demand on jewelry in Hong Kong" [MC1]  {MC means management concern}

Subsequently, the converted theoretical framework item is" to evaluate the impact of gold price increase on depressing consumer demand on jewelry in Hong Kong"


Example 2: "product innovation capability" (zone 2 [organizational capabilities] item)

Refined as: "Management concerned about the adequacy of the product innovation capability of ABC jewelry ltd (HK)" [UMC 2]  {UMC means urgent management concern}

Subsequently, the converted theoretical framework item is "to evaluate the adequacy of the product innovation capability of ABC Jewelry Ltd (HK)"


Example 3: "low staff morale" (Zone 3a [outcomes-related])

Refined as: "Management concerned about the low staff morale status (including impacts) at the jewelry stores of ABC jewelry Ltd (HK)" [MC3]

Subsequently, the converted theoretical framework item is "to evaluate the low staff morale status (including impacts) at the jewelry stores of ABC jewelry Ltd (HK)"

Example 4: "VIP promotion"(Zone 3b [solutions-related])

Refined as: "Unclear how to further strengthen the VIP promotion policy of ABC Jewelry Ltd (HK)" [MC5]

Subsequently, the converted theoretical framework item is "to figure out how to further strengthen the VIP promotion policy of ABC Jewelry Ltd (HK) "


A related reading:

Friday, 13 October 2023

On the two types of dissertation report template for housing studies

 On the two types of dissertation report template for housing studies:


Type 1: the consulting-oriented type.

Type 2: the academic-oriented type.

A study note on the ethnographic approach and its associated topics with e-learning materials

 A study note on the ethnographic approach  and its associated topics with e-learning materials:


A diagram on the ethnographic approach and its associated topics:
















The topics in the diagram with embedded e-learning materials:



Thursday, 12 October 2023

On the long and short forms of management-concern items (zone 1) in the ALRA

On the long and short forms of management-concern items in the ALRA:

In my blog notes on examples of formulation of management-concern items [for zone 1], I have pointed out the relevant considerations involved, which are item expression structure, the variable nature of the items, with hints on linkages with other management-concern items (re: example 1), the management-concern in nature of the items, and specific organizational unit of analysis standpoint (re: example 2). The examples subsequently illustrate how to provide management-concern items formulated with meaning clarity and analysis-facilitation strengths. Nevertheless, high clarity of management-concern item formulation has its cost; it is quite lengthy; putting a set of lengthy items in a management-concerns diagram could be a bit overwhelming for readers to digest. Thus, there is a need to distinguish two forms of management-concern items: the long form and the short form. Two examples are provided in the following table:

The long form of management-concern items

The short form of management-concern items

1.1: Unclear how to introduce effective AI application(s) in  the service operation of ABC Ltd, notably on  tedious task automation

1.2: Unclear on effective AI application in ABC service operation

2.1: Unclear about the AI impacts on service operation on the XXX business sector with special regard to its competitive landscape

2.2: Unclear AI impacts on the competitive landscape of the XXX business sector

Using the short form of management-concern items, in lieu of the long form, to construct the management-concerns diagram makes the diagram less wordy, thus easier to grasp the overall situation as portrayed by the management-concerns diagram. The management-concerns items, in long form, are then employed in the description of the management-concerns diagram in dissertation report writing. Thus, the management-concerns items in the diagram can still be clarified in the report writing.


Note: the the task of item formulation for zone 3a (outcomes-related) is more straightforward, thus the issue of long and short forms does not arise in most situations. Examples of zone 3a items are:

Example 1: worried about the high staff turnover at the retail outlets of ABC Ltd.

Example 2: unhappy about the present business performance as well as its prospect of the Consulting Division of ABC Ltd.


The same situation applies to zone 3b (solutions-related) items. It is straightforward. Examples of zone 3b items are:

Example 1: Unclear how to formulate an effective AI system to support the staff recruitment function of ABC Ltd.

Example 2: Unclear how to improve the existing marketing communication program of ABC Ltd.



A related reading: example 3.

Converting a factual statement into a management-concern item [in zone 1]: example 2

Converting a factual statement into a management-concern item: example 2: a conversation between Student L and Dr. X


Student L: Dr. X, I have formulated a zone 1 management-concern item as follows: "AI can help to replace the job or work that are tedious or duplicated". Could you comment on its appropriateness?

Dr. X: L, could you clarify what is the underlying management concern from the standpoint of your organizational unit of analysis (e.g. The Service Operation Department of ABC Ltd)?

Student L: The management concerns are: (I) that they are unclear about the opportunities and challenges facing the Service Operation Department of ABC Ltd's AI automation, notably on tedious tasks in the service operation of ABC Ltd, and (II) that they are unclear about the AI impacts on service operations on the XXX business sector, thus also on the XXX sector's competitive landscape". {note: ABC Ltd belongs to the XXX business sector}.

Dr. X: In this case you could consider the following two management-concerns items which are clearer in expression for analysis purpose: 

(I) "Unclear how to introduce effective AI application(s) in  the service operation of ABC Ltd, notably on  tedious task automation" (a Zone 3b [solutions-related] item).

(II) "Unclear about the AI impacts on service operation on the XXX business sector with special regard to its competitive landscape" (a Zone 1 [environmental drivers] item).


An additional reminder: these two items (I and II) can be converted into theoretical framework items with clear meaning:

(I) becomes "to evaluate how to introduce  effective AI application in  the service operation of ABC Ltd, notably on tedious task automation" (Zone 3b item in the theoretical framework)

(II) becomes "to evaluate  the AI impacts on service operation on the XXX business sector with special regard to its competitive landscape"


These two theoretical framework items are also useful to serve as an agenda to do literature search, as the key words in these two item statements can be used for literature search purpose:

Key words for (I): "Artificial Intelligence application for service operation"; "Artificial intelligence application adoption"; "Artificial intelligence application implementation". or more broadly, "information system introduction" and "information system adoption".

Key words for (II): "Artificial intelligence application" "AI impact on competitive landscape"; "Business impact of AI" and "competitive landscape".


Finally, a reminder: management-concern items can be urgent (urgent management concern [umc]) and not urgent (management concern [mc]).


Related readings: on example 1 [for zone 1 items] and the long/short forms of management-concerns items. Also study example 3.


Note: for zone 2 [organizational capabilities] items, the item formulation is more straightforward as compared with that of zone 1[environmental drivers]. Zone 2 items are mainly about the weaknesses and inadequacy of certain organizational capability domains, such as human resource management competence, IT management competence, etc. Examples of items for zone 2 are:

Example 1: Management concern item 1 (Zone 2): Worried about the diminishing human resource management competence of ABC Ltd.

Example 2: Management concern item 2 (Zone 2): Uncertain about the adequacy of New Product Development competence of ABC Ltd.




A related reading: