A note on dealing with loss-making customer or product: for advanced management accounting students
Regarding
the subject of advanced management accounting, when we learn that a customer or
a product of a company is losing money, what suitable action could be taken by
the company, other than dropping the customer or the product?
Yes. In advanced
management accounting, a loss-making product or customer is a signal to
investigate cost drivers and improve profitability—not necessarily to drop it.
The key is to distinguish avoidable costs from allocated common fixed
costs, because a product/customer may still contribute positively toward fixed
costs.
Suitable actions
|
Action |
How it improves profitability |
|
Raise or
restructure prices |
Increase the
selling price, reduce discounts, charge separately for costly services, or
introduce minimum order values. This is especially appropriate if the
product/customer consumes disproportionate resources. |
|
Reduce direct
costs |
Negotiate better
input prices, redesign the product, simplify specifications, improve yield,
or use cheaper but acceptable materials/processes. |
|
Improve
processes |
Reduce setup
time, rework, expedited deliveries, returns, small orders, and other
activity-based cost drivers. Activity-based costing helps identify which
activities make the customer or product expensive to serve. |
|
Change the
product mix or bundle |
Sell the
loss-maker together with profitable items, or use it as a deliberate loss
leader to attract sales of higher-margin products. A loss on one item can be
acceptable if the overall bundle or customer relationship is profitable. |
|
Increase sales
volume or cross-selling |
Encourage the
customer to buy more profitable products, increase order size, or improve
capacity utilization so fixed costs are spread over more units. |
|
Outsource or
change supply method |
Buy the product
rather than make it, or change production/delivery arrangements if that
lowers avoidable costs. |
|
Renegotiate
customer terms |
Require larger
orders, longer delivery lead times, payment for special services, or lower
after-sales support. |
|
Reallocate
resources |
Shift scarce
capacity, marketing spending, or sales effort toward products/customers with
higher contribution margins. |
|
Retain
strategically |
Keep the
product/customer temporarily if it supports market entry, maintains a
complete product range, protects a major relationship, or avoids losing
complementary sales. Such qualitative and strategic factors should be
considered alongside the numbers. |
Important accounting point
Do not decide
solely from a reported segment loss. Compare the contribution margin
earned with and without the product/customer, and consider only relevant,
avoidable revenues and costs; common fixed costs that continue regardless
of the decision should not automatically be charged against it.
For example, if a
customer generates HK$100,000 contribution but is assigned HK$120,000 of
costs—of which HK$40,000 are unavoidable shared overheads—the customer still
contributes HK$100,000 toward those unavoidable costs. Dropping it could reduce
total company profit unless at least HK$100,000 of costs are genuinely avoided.
Practical approach
1.
Recalculate
profitability using activity-based costing or customer profitability analysis.
2.
Separate avoidable
from unavoidable costs.
3.
Identify the
activities causing the loss, such as frequent small orders, excessive
customization, returns, or urgent delivery.
4.
Choose a
corrective action—pricing, process improvement, product redesign, or
relationship management.
5.
Reassess after
implementation; discontinue only if no feasible action can make the
relationship contribute more than its avoidable costs.