A study note on how to utilize literature review findings of an individual academic article

A study note on how to utilize literature review findings of an individual academic article (information from poe.com)

My question 1: "I am a Research Methods student. A query on literature review of mine is that, when reviewing an academic article with a similar research theme as mine, what are the main usages of the academic information from that reviewed article for my own literature review of my research project? I could discern the following information types from the reviewed academic article as concept definitions, academic theories, research methods used, theoretical perspectives, and empirical findings."

The reply: "When reviewing an academic article for your literature review, you can extract several key types of information to enhance your own research project. Here's a breakdown of how you can use the information types you've identified:

1. Concept Definitions:

   • Usage: Clarify key terms and concepts relevant to your research. This ensures that your audience understands the terminology you are using.
   • Example: If the article defines a specific concept related to your theme, you can adopt this definition to maintain consistency.

2. Academic Theories:

   • Usage: Integrate established theories that support your research framework. This can help position your work within existing literature.
   • Example: If the article discusses a relevant theory, you can reference it to justify your research questions or hypotheses.

3. Research Methods Used:

   • Usage: Identify methodologies that may be applicable to your own study. This can guide your methodological choices.
   • Example: If the article employs a particular qualitative or quantitative method successfully, consider how you might adapt it for your research.

4. Theoretical Perspectives:

   • Usage: Explore different theoretical lenses through which your topic can be viewed. This can deepen your analysis and interpretation of your findings.
   • Example: If the article adopts a specific theoretical perspective, you can either align with it or contrast your findings against it.

5. Empirical Findings:

   • Usage: Use the findings to contextualize your research. This helps in identifying gaps that your study might address.
   • Example: Highlighting how your results will contribute to or challenge the findings presented in the article can strengthen your argument.

By leveraging these types of information, you strengthen the foundation of your literature review, making it more comprehensive and relevant to your research project."

My question 2: "Are there any other specific suggestions with reference to the fields of (1) business management, (2) housing studies, and (3) accounting and finance?"

The reply: "Here are specific suggestions for conducting literature reviews in the fields of business management, housing studies, and accounting and finance:

1. Business Management

• Identify Key Models: Look for established models or frameworks (e.g., SWOT analysis, Porter's Five Forces) that can provide a theoretical backbone for your research.
• Explore Leadership Theories: Examine various leadership styles and their impact on organizational performance, as this is a crucial area in business management.
• Assess Market Trends: Utilize empirical findings related to market dynamics and consumer behavior to support your research on strategic decision-making.

2. Housing Studies

• Examine Policy Impacts: Review literature on housing policies and their implications for social equity and urban development to inform your analysis.
• Analyze Housing Market Trends: Incorporate empirical studies on housing demand, affordability, and supply to contextualize your research questions.
• Study Community Dynamics: Investigate how community engagement and social capital affect housing outcomes, which can provide a unique angle to your research.

3. Accounting and Finance

• Review Accounting Standards: Familiarize yourself with relevant accounting principles and standards (e.g., IFRS, GAAP) that may impact your research.
• Explore Financial Theories: Look for foundational theories (e.g., Modern Portfolio Theory, Efficient Market Hypothesis) that can guide your financial analysis.
• Investigate Risk Management: Analyze literature on risk assessment and management strategies, especially in relation to financial decision-making.

By focusing on these specific areas within each field, you can enhance the relevance and depth of your literature review, making it more impactful for your research project."

References: 

A collection of notes on information extraction from an individual academic article.

A collection of blog notes on using chatgpt for research purpose.