A note on how a research philosophy can influence the formulation of a dissertation proposal: for Housing Studies students (information from perplexity.ai)
My question: "Regarding my Housing Studies dissertation theme of "the influence of the Hong Kong housing policy on the citizens' near-term home purchase intention", please provide an example of a dissertation proposal with (1) dissertation project title, (2) 3 research issues to respond to, (3) 3 research objectives, (4) 2 research questions, and (5) 2 preferred research methods (with specific data gathering and data analysis methods on each research method) to use, to each of the following 4 cases: (1) the employment of positivism as the project philosophy, (2) the employment of interpretivism as the project philosophy, (3) the employment of pragmatism as the project philosophy and (4) the employment of critical realism as the project philosophy."
The reply: "Here is an example of a dissertation proposal themed "The influence of the Hong Kong housing policy on the citizens' near-term home purchase intention," tailored to four different research philosophies: positivism, interpretivism, pragmatism, and critical realism.
Positivism Dissertation Proposal
- Project Title:Quantitative Analysis of Hong Kong Housing Policy Impact on Citizens' Near-Term Home Purchase Intention
Research Issues:
Statistical relationship between housing policy changes and home purchase intention.
Impact of economic indicators and housing policy on property purchasing behavior.
Measurement of citizen confidence levels in relation to housing policies.
Research Objectives:
To quantify correlations between housing policy amendments and citizens' purchase intentions.
To statistically analyze the effect of economic conditions on home buying confidence.
To evaluate predictive factors influencing near-term home purchase decisions.
Research Questions:
What is the measurable effect of Hong Kong housing policies on citizens’ intentions to buy homes soon?
How do economic trends and policy changes statistically influence citizen purchase confidence?
Preferred Research Methods:
Quantitative survey: Structured questionnaires with Likert-scale items distributed to households to gather numerical data on purchase intentions.
Data Analysis: Statistical techniques such as regression analysis and correlation tests to identify relationships between variables.
Interpretivism Dissertation Proposal
- Project Title:Understanding Citizen Perceptions of Hong Kong Housing Policy and Its Influence on Home Purchase Intention
Research Issues:
Subjective interpretations of housing policy effects on purchase decisions.
Social and cultural narratives shaping home buying confidence.
Lived experiences of citizens regarding housing market policies.
Research Objectives:
To explore how individuals perceive and interpret housing policy influences on their purchase intentions.
To understand the cultural and social context affecting homeownership desire.
To analyze the narratives that shape citizens' housing-related confidence.
Research Questions:
How do Hong Kong citizens interpret the influence of housing policies on their home buying intentions?
What cultural and social factors shape these interpretations?
Preferred Research Methods:
Semi-structured interviews: Conduct in-depth interviews with purposively sampled participants to gather rich, qualitative insights.
Thematic analysis: Analyze interview transcripts to identify key themes and meanings related to housing policy perceptions.
Pragmatism Dissertation Proposal
- Project Title:Practical Impacts of Hong Kong Housing Policy on Citizens' Home Purchase Decisions
Research Issues:
Real-world effects of housing policy on purchasing behavior.
Interaction between economic trends and buying strategies.
Adaptive citizen strategies amidst housing market fluctuations.
Research Objectives:
To identify practical approaches people use when deciding to purchase homes.
To evaluate housing policies' responsiveness to real economic conditions and citizen needs.
To investigate how pragmatic considerations shape purchase confidence.
Research Questions:
What practical strategies do citizens employ in response to housing policy and economic changes?
How effective are current policies in meeting citizens’ real-world housing purchase needs?
Preferred Research Methods:
Mixed methods: Combine surveys to capture broader behavior patterns and interviews for in-depth understanding.
Data analysis: Use statistical analysis on survey data; use content or thematic analysis on interview data.
Critical Realism Dissertation Proposal
- Project Title:Exploring the Structural Influences of Hong Kong Housing Policy on Citizens’ Home Purchase Confidence
Research Issues:
Underlying socio-economic mechanisms affecting housing policy and purchase intention.
Effects of systemic inequalities on housing market confidence.
Historical and contextual factors shaping policy impacts and citizen perceptions.
Research Objectives:
To uncover deeper socio-economic structures that influence housing policy outcomes.
To analyze how systemic inequalities affect citizens’ confidence in purchasing homes.
To examine historical factors shaping contemporary housing market dynamics.
Research Questions:
What socio-economic structures influence the link between housing policy and purchase intention?
How do systemic inequalities impact citizens’ confidence in the housing market?
Preferred Research Methods:
Case study approach: Utilize document analysis, policy review, and interviews to investigate socio-economic structures.
Critical discourse analysis and thematic analysis: Examine housing policy texts and interview data to identify underlying mechanisms and power relations.
These four proposal examples illustrate how different research philosophies shape the framing of research issues, objectives, questions, and data collection and analysis methods regarding the influence of Hong Kong housing policy on citizens' near-term home purchase intentions."
A collection of blog notes on using chatgpt for research purpose.
No comments:
Post a Comment