Monday 15 January 2018

Typology of plagiarism and related practices

Typology of plagiarism and related practices


Prepared by Joseph, K.K. Ho Dated: January 15, 2018
Using Ho, J.K.K. 2017. "A survey study of perceptions on the scholar-practitioner notion: The Hong Kong case" Joseph KK Ho e-resources blog December 1 (url address: http://josephho33.blogspot.hk/2017/12/a-survey-study-of-perceptions-on.html).

Type 1: classical plagiarism: no quotation marks and no citations
E.g.  content coming  from http://josephho33.blogspot.hk/2017/12/a-survey-study-of-perceptions-on.html:

Scholar-practitioners are people who are intellectually competent as well as active in pursuing and sharing theoretical knowledge with high practical value to others (Ho, 2014a). For them, scholar-practitioner is their professional identity. Some writers as well as universities that promote their Ph.D. and D.B.A. programmes also specify that scholar-practitioners should hold a doctorate degree (Ho, 2014a). The reason is that these programmes provide vigorous education on research methods and intellectual learning in business management, e.g., Chan (2008), to produce scholar-leaders (Cafolla, 2012). Dwelling on scholar-practitioners in business management, Ho (2014a) points out that, being active in both the academic and business communities creates unique complexity to the career development and work-life balance of scholar-practitioners, e.g., experience of role conflicts. Such complexity facing scholar-practitioners has been studied in the academic literature under four main topics (Ho, 2014a): (i) the profiles and career development patterns of scholar-practitioner, (ii) the role conflicts and professional development challenges, (iii) ways to bridge knowledge-action gap in management, and (iv) formulation of appropriate approaches and contents of business management education. In this regard, a closely related research theme is on the work-life balance management in managerial intellectual learning (Ho, 2014d). 

Type 2: near-plagiarism: Quotation marks added but no citations:

"Scholar-practitioners are people who are intellectually competent as well as active in pursuing and sharing theoretical knowledge with high practical value to others (Ho, 2014a). For them, scholar-practitioner is their professional identity. Some writers as well as universities that promote their Ph.D. and D.B.A. programmes also specify that scholar-practitioners should hold a doctorate degree (Ho, 2014a). The reason is that these programmes provide vigorous education on research methods and intellectual learning in business management, e.g., Chan (2008), to produce scholar-leaders (Cafolla, 2012). Dwelling on scholar-practitioners in business management, Ho (2014a) points out that, being active in both the academic and business communities creates unique complexity to the career development and work-life balance of scholar-practitioners, e.g., experience of role conflicts. Such complexity facing scholar-practitioners has been studied in the academic literature under four main topics (Ho, 2014a): (i) the profiles and career development patterns of scholar-practitioner, (ii) the role conflicts and professional development challenges, (iii) ways to bridge knowledge-action gap in management, and (iv) formulation of appropriate approaches and contents of business management education. In this regard, a closely related research theme is on the work-life balance management in managerial intellectual learning (Ho, 2014d)".

Type 3a: Abuse of quotation I: Quotation marks and citations provided, but the size of the copied content large; a few instances
"Scholar-practitioners are people who are intellectually competent as well as active in pursuing and sharing theoretical knowledge with high practical value to others (Ho, 2014a). For them, scholar-practitioner is their professional identity. Some writers as well as universities that promote their Ph.D. and D.B.A. programmes also specify that scholar-practitioners should hold a doctorate degree (Ho, 2014a). The reason is that these programmes provide vigorous education on research methods and intellectual learning in business management, e.g., Chan (2008), to produce scholar-leaders (Cafolla, 2012). Dwelling on scholar-practitioners in business management, Ho (2014a) points out that, being active in both the academic and business communities creates unique complexity to the career development and work-life balance of scholar-practitioners, e.g., experience of role conflicts. Such complexity facing scholar-practitioners has been studied in the academic literature under four main topics (Ho, 2014a): (i) the profiles and career development patterns of scholar-practitioner, (ii) the role conflicts and professional development challenges, (iii) ways to bridge knowledge-action gap in management, and (iv) formulation of appropriate approaches and contents of business management education. In this regard, a closely related research theme is on the work-life balance management in managerial intellectual learning (Ho, 2014d)" (Ho, 2017).

Type 3b: Abuse of quotation I: Quotation marks and citations provided, but the size of the copied content large; many instances



Implications of plagiarism and related  practice types
Implications
Type 1
Type 2
Type 3
Turnitin report:
Coloring of copied content
Yes
No
No
Effect on similarity score of Turnitin
Increase
NIL
NIL
No. of instances
Small
Large
Small
Large
Small
Large
Impact on plagiarism judgement (provisional rating[1]):
(0: not serious
5: very serious)
4
5
3
4
2
3



Meaning of citation (re: http://www.plagiarism.org/article/what-is-citation)
A "citation" is the way you tell your readers that certain material in your work came from another source. It also gives your readers the information necessary to find that source again, including:
  • information about the author
  • the title of the work
  • the name and location of the company that published your copy of the source
  • the date your copy was published
  • the page numbers of the material you are borrowing





[1] Rating on them could be revised from time to time for different institutions

No comments:

Post a Comment