A brief teaching note on document study as a research method

A brief teaching note on document study as a research method (information from perplexity.ai)

My question 1: "Briefly highlight the main ideas of document as a research method in social science with reference to the following topics: (1) favored research philosophy, (2) favored research method design techniques, (3) favored research method design quality criteria, (4) favored data gathering and data analysis techniques, and (5) favored researcher's impression management approach in conducting the document study."

The reply: "To address the main ideas of using documents as a research method in social science under the specified topics, the approach includes the following:

(1) Favored Research Philosophy:

Document study in social science often aligns with interpretivist or constructivist research philosophies, which emphasize understanding the meanings and contexts behind the document data rather than treating reality as purely objective and stable. This approach values multiple perspectives and the complexity of social phenomena as reflected in documents.

(2) Favored Research Method Design Techniques:

Document study leverages qualitative methods such as content analysis, thematic analysis, and case study approaches where documents are systematically reviewed and interpreted. Mixed-methods design can also be employed, integrating quantitative coding when needed to enhance rigor.

(3) Favored Research Method Design Quality Criteria:

Quality criteria favor credibility (validity), dependability (reliability), and confirmability. Triangulation using multiple documents or combining document data with interviews and observations is common to enhance construct validity and ensure depth. Transparency in data collection and interpretation processes is crucial for rigor.

(4) Favored Data Gathering and Data Analysis Techniques:

Data gathering in document study involves collecting relevant texts such as archival records, reports, official documents, media articles, and other written artifacts. Analysis techniques include coding data for themes or categories, narrative analysis, and discourse analysis to interpret meanings and social contexts.

(5) Favored Researcher's Impression Management Approach:

Researchers managing impression in document studies tend to adopt roles of detached observers or “consultants” to minimize bias. They carefully manage their presence and interpretation by being reflexive about their own influence, maintaining transparency, and using systematic, replicable procedures to reduce subjectivity and credible impression management in reporting findings.

This summary integrates key ideas about document studies within a social science research framework: interpretivist philosophy, qualitative (or mixed) method design, rigor through credibility and triangulation, textual data gathering and thematic analysis, and reflexive impression management by researchers. These points collectively define document study as a rigorous and contextually rich research method in social sciences."

My question 2: "Please provide 1 brief example of its application in the context of an MBA dissertation project and another example in the context of a Housing Studies dissertation project."

The reply: "Here are brief examples of applying document study as a research method in dissertation projects:

MBA Dissertation Example:

A student researching "The Influence of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) on Organizational Performance" could use document study to analyze annual CSR reports, sustainability disclosures, company financial statements, and relevant media coverage. Through thematic content analysis of these documents, the student can explore how CSR activities are framed and reported, linking documents' narrative tone and data with performance outcomes to draw conclusions.

Housing Studies Dissertation Example:

A student investigating "Policy Impacts on Affordable Housing Development" might conduct a document study reviewing government housing policy documents, planning committee meeting minutes, developer reports, and NGO publications. The student would analyze these texts qualitatively to identify policy priorities, stakeholder concerns, and implementation challenges, triangulating diverse sources to assess how policy shapes affordable housing outcomes in practice.

Both examples demonstrate use of documents as rich data sources to provide contextual understanding and triangulation, fitting well with qualitative, interpretivist research philosophies and systematic analysis methods in social science dissertations. The researcher manages interpretation by transparently documenting coding and analysis procedures."

My question 3: "Are document study and qualitative content analysis the same as a research method?"

The reply: "Document study and qualitative content analysis are related but not exactly the same as research methods.

Document study broadly refers to the systematic examination and interpretation of documents to understand their content, context, and meaning. It focuses on analyzing the structure, purpose, and socio-political context of documents to derive insights. Document study often involves understanding explicit messages as well as underlying themes, trends, and authorial intent.

Qualitative content analysis is a more specific methodological approach used within document study or other textual analyses. It systematically categorizes and interprets textual data to identify themes, patterns, and meanings. Unlike document study, which may consider broader contextual and structural aspects, qualitative content analysis focuses on coding text to reveal deeper meanings and emergent categories often in an iterative, interpretive manner.

In summary:

• Document study is the overarching process of analyzing documents as data, including context and purpose.

• Qualitative content analysis is a rigorous technique within document study focused on coding and interpreting textual data for themes and meanings.

They complement each other; qualitative content analysis is often the method applied within a document study to analyze the text content systematically."

A collection of blog notes on using chatgpt for research purpose.