A study note on gatekeeper and gatekeeper consent form in dissertation projects (information from perplexity.ai)
My question 1: "What are "gatekeeper" and "gatekeeper consent form" in dissertation projects all about with reference to the fields of business management and housing studies?"
The reply: "In dissertation projects within business management and housing studies, a gatekeeper is an individual or authority who controls access to a research setting, participants, or data that the researcher needs to conduct their study. This could be a manager, director, administrator, or any person responsible for granting permission to enter an organization, institution, or community relevant to the research28. For example, in business management, a gatekeeper might be a company’s HR manager who controls access to employees for a study, while in housing studies, it could be a housing association manager or community leader who controls access to residents or housing data.
A gatekeeper consent form is a formal document used to obtain permission from the gatekeeper to allow the researcher to access the site, participants, or data. This form outlines the purpose of the research, what the gatekeeper’s role will involve (such as facilitating participant recruitment or distributing information), and assurances about confidentiality and data use. It ensures that the gatekeeper understands the research scope and consents voluntarily to assist the researcher69.
Key Points about Gatekeepers and Gatekeeper Consent Forms:
Role of Gatekeeper: Controls access to research participants or data, especially when the researcher has no direct access. They may facilitate recruitment or distribution of research materials but do not usually participate in the research themselves12.
Gatekeeper Consent Form Content:
Explanation of the study’s purpose and researcher’s identity.
Description of what assistance is requested from the gatekeeper.
Clarification that participation by individuals is voluntary and confidential.
Information on how data will be handled and used.
Contact details for further questions.
Statement that the gatekeeper can withdraw consent at any time without consequences6.
Ethical Considerations: Gatekeeper consent is part of ethical research practice, ensuring respect for organizational autonomy and participant protection. However, gatekeeper consent is not always required, for example, when research involves public observation or participants acting independently outside institutional roles9.
Relevance in Business Management and Housing Studies:
In business management, gatekeepers often manage access to employees, organizational data, or corporate environments.
In housing studies, gatekeepers may be community leaders, housing managers, or officials who control access to residents or housing-related data.
Gatekeeper consent helps navigate organizational or community protocols and ethical requirements, facilitating smooth and legitimate research access26.
In summary, gatekeepers and gatekeeper consent forms are crucial in managing access and ethical compliance in dissertation research, especially in fields like business management and housing studies where access to organizations or communities is controlled by specific individuals or authorities. They ensure that research is conducted with proper permissions and respect for institutional and participant rights."
My question 2: "Under what conditions that the requirement to obtain gatekeeper consent can be set aside for a dissertation project?"
The reply: "The requirement to obtain gatekeeper consent for a dissertation project can be set aside under certain conditions, typically when:
Research involves observation in public spaces without direct interaction with participants. If the study only observes people in public settings without engaging them, gatekeeper consent is not required4.
Participants are adults (over 18), legally competent, acting voluntarily, and recruited independently of any organization or institution. When participants are approached in their personal capacity, not as members of an organization, gatekeeper consent can be waived, provided participants give informed consent themselves4.
Participants are recruited in public spaces and are fully informed about the research and consent to participate. Here, gatekeeper consent is unnecessary if participants themselves consent to the study after being informed4.
The gatekeeper’s role is limited to assisting recruitment or distributing research materials without formal permission. For example, if an HR manager forwards a survey link to employees, their action implies consent, so prior gatekeeper consent is not mandatory4.
There is a conflict of interest between the gatekeeper and the research aims, or informing the gatekeeper could cause harm or adverse outcomes to participants. In such cases, researchers can request a gatekeeper waiver from the ethics committee, providing a clear justification. For instance, if restaurant owners might block access to waitstaff due to sensitive wage-related research, a waiver may be granted4.
When gatekeepers are informal and do not have official authority to grant or withhold permission, or when cultural norms allow participants autonomy without formal gatekeeper consent. Researchers should still respect local customs but may not need formal gatekeeper consent45.
In summary, gatekeeper consent can be set aside when research is conducted in public settings without direct interaction, involves autonomous adult participants acting independently, when gatekeepers only facilitate recruitment without formal permission, or when ethical review grants a waiver due to conflicts or potential harm from gatekeeper involvement. Researchers must document and justify such waivers through their ethics application process4."
My question 3: "Under what conditions that the requirement to obtain gatekeeper consent must be obtained for a dissertation project?"
The reply: "The requirement to obtain gatekeeper consent for a dissertation project must be met under the following conditions:
When participants are recruited based on their membership or affiliation with an organization, institution, company, or association. For example, if participants are employees, residents, students, or members of a specific group, permission from the relevant gatekeeper (such as a manager, director, or community leader) is required to access them for research2.
When the research setting or site is controlled by an authority who has the official power to grant or deny access. This includes formal gatekeepers like heads of agencies, service providers, or institutional leaders who oversee the environment where the research will take place25.
When the ethics review process mandates gatekeeper permission as part of the approval requirements. For instance, studies involving NHS participants or other regulated environments often require gatekeeper consent before ethical approval is granted1.
When the research involves accessing sensitive or restricted data or populations where unauthorized access could cause harm or breach confidentiality. Gatekeeper consent ensures that the research respects organizational protocols and participant protection2.
When the gatekeeper’s consent is explicitly required to proceed with recruitment or data collection activities. The gatekeeper must be named in the ethics application, and approval is contingent on receiving their permission2.
When the research is conducted within institutions such as universities, schools, clinics, or workplaces, where institutional policies require gatekeeper approval before research can be conducted on site or with their members56.
In summary, gatekeeper consent must be obtained when research involves participants affiliated with an organization or institution, when access to the research setting is controlled by an official authority, when ethics committees require it, or when institutional policies mandate it. This consent is essential to ensure ethical compliance, protect participants, and respect organizational governance."
My question 4: "What are the main information provided in a typical gatekeeper informed consent form?"
The reply: "A typical gatekeeper informed consent form provides the following main information:
Title of the Study: Clear and consistent title of the research project.
Introduction and Purpose: Explanation of who the researcher is, the purpose of the study, and why the gatekeeper’s assistance is requested. This includes a neutral description of the study’s aims and the researcher’s affiliation or qualification being pursued.
Role of the Gatekeeper: Detailed description of what the gatekeeper is being asked to do, such as facilitating access, distributing information, or helping recruit participants. It clarifies that the gatekeeper’s role is limited to facilitation and that participants will contact the researcher directly.
What Participation Involves: Explanation of what participation means for the gatekeeper and the participants, including the nature of the research activities, expected duration, and any topics to be covered. It also states that participation is voluntary and outlines any potential risks or benefits.
Data Access and Confidentiality: Information on who will have access to the data collected, assurances about confidentiality and anonymity, and conditions under which confidentiality might be broken (e.g., legal obligations).
Use and Dissemination of Results: Explanation of how the research findings will be used, including plans for publication, conferences, or teaching, or simply submission of the dissertation.
Contact Information: Names, affiliations, and contact details of the researcher(s) and academic supervisor(s) for further questions or clarifications.
Consent Statement: A declaration that the gatekeeper voluntarily agrees to facilitate the research, understands their role, knows they can withdraw at any time without consequences, and acknowledges confidentiality of data.
Signatures and Dates: Spaces for the gatekeeper’s signature and date, as well as the researcher’s signature confirming informed consent has been obtained.
This structure ensures the gatekeeper is fully informed about the study, their role, and ethical considerations before consenting to facilitate the research125."
No comments:
Post a Comment