An examination of the context of study of an academic article 01: for MBA students

An examination of the context of study of an academic article 01: for MBA students (information from chatpdf.com) 

[This note illustrates what to write about on the project background of a dissertation project of the academic-oriented type]

The article studied is : "Labour-cost retrenchment strategies in times of crisis: Comparing market reactions to flexible and rigid strategies" Long Range Planning" Long Range Planning.

My question 1: "What are the research objectives of the study?"

The reply: "The research objectives of the study are twofold: First, to investigate the effects of flexible labor-cost retrenchment strategies (such as wage-based and functional flexibility) on a firm’s market value in comparison to rigid strategies (like total downsizing). Second, to examine how these effects differ when firms possess high levels of knowledge assets, particularly in a stakeholder-capitalism environment like Japan. The study aims to fill the gap in the literature regarding the impact and perception of flexible strategies during times of crisis and how they influence investor judgments, especially regarding the protection of firm knowledge assets."

My question 2: "Does the article discuss how the research objectives are related to the relevant academic context, thus clarifying the academic value of them?"

The reply: "Yes, the article discusses how the research objectives are situated within the broader academic context, thereby emphasizing their academic value. It highlights that previous research on retrenchment strategies has primarily focused on rigid strategies, neglecting the variety and potential benefits of flexible approaches, especially in stakeholder-capitalism environments. The study addresses this gap by proposing and analyzing flexible strategies—such as wage-based and functional flexibility—and their impact on market valuation, which extends the current understanding of retrenchment practices. Furthermore, it connects the research to institutional theory and resource-based views, emphasizing the importance of knowledge assets in evaluating firm responses during crises. This contextualization clarifies that the study advances scholarly understanding by broadening the conceptual framework of retrenchment strategies and their implications, particularly regarding knowledge protection and stakeholder norms."

My question 3: "Does the article discuss how the research objectives are related to the relevant public media-related context, thus clarifying the practical value of them?"

The reply: "Yes, the article relates its research objectives to the public media context, demonstrating their practical significance. It utilizes data from newspaper articles—specifically reports from the Nihon Keizai Shinbun during Japan’s 2008–2009 financial crisis—to analyze publicly announced retrenchment strategies. This media-based data collection underscores the importance of media reports in understanding corporate behavior and investor perceptions during crises. By examining how flexible versus rigid strategies are presented in media and the subsequent market reactions, the study emphasizes its relevance to real-world corporate communication and stakeholder engagement, thus highlighting its practical value in informing management practices, investor responses, and policy considerations during times of economic distress."

My question 4: "Does the article discuss how the research objectives are related to the researcher's positionality, thus clarifying the researcher's preferred study orientation and personal intellectual curiosity in the study?"

The reply: "The article briefly addresses aspects related to the researchers' approach and validation procedures, such as the intra-rater agreement score, consultations with management professors, and validation with a business executive, which suggest an awareness of methodological rigor and the importance of contextual understanding. However, it does not explicitly discuss how the researchers' personal positionality, perspectives, or intellectual curiosity influenced their study design, interpretation, or focus. There is limited reflection within the provided content on their personal orientation, values, or biases shaping the research objectives. Therefore, the article does not explicitly clarify the researchers’ positionality or their personal intellectual curiosity related to the study."

My question 5: "Does the article indicate the originality, academic and practical values of the study?"

The reply: "Yes, the article clearly articulates the originality and both academic and practical values of the study. It emphasizes that this research is the first to introduce a comprehensive set of flexible retrenchment strategies, thereby challenging and extending existing theories that predominantly focus on rigid strategies in shareholder-capitalism contexts. The authors highlight the theoretical contribution of developing an institutionally embedded resource-based view (RBV) of the firm, particularly emphasizing the role of knowledge assets and innovation in crisis responses. Practically, the study provides insights into how firms, especially innovative ones, can strategically manage labor costs during economic crises, which is valuable for managers and policymakers aiming to improve crisis management strategies and stakeholder engagement. Overall, the paper’s contributions are positioned as significant advancements in both theory and practice."

My question 6: "Besides the research objectives, does the article indicate any specific research questions to study?"

The reply: "Yes, the article specifies two main research questions guiding the study aside from the broader objectives. These are:

1. What effects do flexible strategies for labor-cost retrenchment (e.g., wage-based and functional flexibility) have on market value compared with rigid strategies (such as pure downsizing)?
2. What effects do flexible strategies have, compared to rigid strategies, when firms have a high level of knowledge assets?

These questions focus on understanding the impact of different retrenchment strategies on market valuation and how these effects may vary depending on a firm’s level of knowledge assets, particularly in the context of Japan’s financial crisis."

A collection of blog notes on using chatgpt for research purpose.